I completely agree with your previous point. Golden Nuggets had many, many issues, and the fact it was in such a poor state before the Sheriffs Showdown refurb happened exemplifies this. It's a shame, because I thought the targets were far better on GN, and the music, and the animatronics programs (which were much more in time with the targets being hit). Sheriffs Showdown just takes these issues to a whole new level, when really it should of been a major opportunity to give the whole ride a much more extensive makeover. The LED 1s are okay. I suppose they can be customized quite a bit but as things are currently, they reset way too fast which makes spamming a major issue in the ride. You only need to shoot in one area as they come back so quickly. What GN did so well is that the targets remained hit until the animatronic effect wired up to the target finished. The golden targets giving more points are a cool idea, but their execution is poor. YOU'VE GOT A BONUS being drummed in to my ears 20 times in a row isn't exactly the most pleasant thing in the world. The bonus score is far better when you hit 3 cans in a row as it used to be.
I'm not denying that there were some good and needed changes that were addressed for Sheriffs. The queueline is excellent with nice rock work and a good use of the old Jungle Palladium waterwheel underneath. The attempts to split the scenes in the ride are also good and much needed (since Golden Nuggets first opened this has been an issue so it's good that it's been addressed). It opens up the opportunity for audio to be used better in scenes that are now clearly more enclosed, but sadly the audio remains very poor and unoriginal.
Overall, the ride refurb job has been a very lackluster upgrade, and as you point out, it's now an incredibly unreliable ride in terms of effects and animatronics. Unfortunate for Drayton as they clearly had the right ideas but went under budget when really the ride needed much more extensive overhauls. But hey, it's better than Duel's 'upgrade', which has that much bright UV paint it looks more like a club or laser station and where you can see literally all of the mechanisms behind the illusions. It's not *that* bad at least ?
I personally think that both Golden Nuggets and Haunting may have had their day. Both originally excellent rides but age has not been kind to either. I think that it'd be great if both rides went at some point over the next few years and were replaced with a single, larger, tracked, dark ride.